In brief
A conflict between heirs is a legal dispute regarding the distribution, execution, or content of an estate between persons who jointly claim the inheritance.
- Disagreements over the sale or valuation of assets, such as a home or business, can block the settlement of an estate for a long period.
- In many cases, a disinherited child can claim the statutory share, even if the will does not mention it.
- Heirs have a right to information regarding the size of the estate; if that information is not provided, legal action may be necessary.
- Depending on the stance of the parties involved, consultation, mediation, binding advice, or legal proceedings are the possible routes.
- An inheritance lawyer determines your legal position and guides you in limiting further escalation.
What is a conflict between heirs?
A conflict between heirs is a dispute regarding the distribution, execution, or content of an estate. Heirs are joint owners of the estate until it has been divided. As long as that division does not take place, they must make decisions jointly. This can lead to disagreement.
Conflicts are rarely just about money. Often, recognition, trust, and old family relationships play a role. This is precisely why a clear legal analysis is important: it provides insight into who is entitled to what, independent of the emotional dynamics.
How does a conflict between heirs arise?
After a death, emotions and financial interests converge. This can lead to tensions, particularly when:
- There is no will or the will is unclearly formulated.
- Assets are difficult to value, such as a home, a business, or securities.
- One of the heirs has more information than the others or was more involved in the care of the deceased.
- The executor does not act transparently or exceeds the limits of their authority.
- It concerns blended families, where children from different relationships inherit together.
When the estate contains debts and heirs disagree on acceptance, beneficiary acceptance can offer a way out to avoid personal liability.
In many of these situations, guidance from an inheritance lawyer is wise to prevent further escalation.
Common situations
Sale of the parental home
When one heir wants to sell the property and another does not, the distribution of the estate can stall. In many cases, the court can be asked to make a decision. Depending on the circumstances, other routes are also possible, such as a buyout or an amicable settlement.
Disinheritance and the statutory share
When a child is disinherited, the right of inheritance expires, but the claim to the statutory share does not automatically expire. This is the legal minimum portion of the estate that a child can claim. This claim must be actively invoked and within the statutory period.
Right to information
Under certain circumstances, heirs have the right to inspect the inventory of the estate and the financial records of the deceased. If that information is structurally withheld, legal action may be necessary.
Dispute regarding the executor
An executor is charged with the settlement of the estate. He must act within the limits of the will and the law. In case of doubt about his actions or suspected exceeding of authority, judicial review may follow.
How do inheritance legal proceedings work?
Not every conflict needs to go directly to court. In many cases, a structured approach leads to a solution sooner.
- Legal analysis
Determining the legal position of each heir. - Formal notice or position statement
Formally making claims known. - Negotiation
Aimed at an agreement without judicial intervention. - Mediation
A neutral third party guides the consultation between heirs. - Legal proceedings at court
If consultation does not lead to a result.
Depending on the circumstances, not every step is necessary. The right route depends on the nature of the dispute and the willingness of the parties to consult.
When is quick action important?
Timely legal advice can strengthen your position. Action is particularly important when:
- Statutory deadlines are about to expire, such as for the claim to the statutory share.
- Vermogensbestanddelen worden verkocht of overgedragen zonder instemming van alle erfgenamen.
- Debts in the estate are mounting and liability is imminent; see also inheritance with debts.
Information is structurally withheld
International aspects
When one of the heirs lives abroad, or when assets are located outside the Netherlands, additional questions regarding jurisdiction and applicable law arise. Which law applies depends on the place of residence of the deceased, the location of the assets, and any international treaties.
You can read more about this on our page about international inheritance law. International situations require a careful legal assessment.
Example from practice
After the death of their mother, a disagreement arose between three children regarding the valuation of a family business. One of them felt excluded from the information provided by the executor. By first legally determining what information had to be shared and what rights each heir had, a clear negotiating position could be taken. This cleared the way for consultation on the distribution.
Every situation requires its own legal assessment.
Written by Carla Simmelink, inheritance lawyer at Simmelink Lawyers.
Our Attorneys at Law
The Simmelink Lawyers team specializes in family law, International family law, and inheritance law.
The lawyers combine legal expertise with international experience.
Clients are guided by one dedicated lawyer who oversees the entire process and communicates discreetly.
In complex financial matters or an international component, a specialized lawyer is important.
We strive for legally correct, practically feasible agreements that give you predictability and peace of mind.
Carla Simmelink – Family Law Attorney, International Family Law and Inheritance Law
Family Law Attorney, International Family Law and Inheritance Law
Valerie Lingg – Family Law Attorney, International Family Law
Family Law Attorney, International Family Law
Eva Zaunbrecher-Boschloo – Family Law Attorney, International Family Law
Lawyer at Law (International) Family Law
Clients are guided by a dedicated lawyer who oversees the entire file and communicates discreetly.
Frequently Asked Questions
Would you like to have your position mapped out? Schedule a consultation. If you are already involved in legal proceedings, you can also request a second opinion.
That depends on the ownership structure and the phase of the settlement. When the property belongs to the undivided estate, all heirs are joint owners and unanimity is, in principle, required. In many cases, a judge can be asked to make a decision if the parties cannot reach an agreement. Depending on the circumstances, other routes are also possible, such as a buyout or division and distribution via the court.
Under certain circumstances, heirs have the right to inspect the inventory of the estate and the financial records of the deceased. If that information is not provided, legal action may be necessary in the form of a formal notice or, if necessary, a request to the court. In many cases, a formal legal request already leads to cooperation.
Binding advice is a procedure in which parties submit the dispute to an independent expert, whose ruling they have agreed in advance to accept. It is an alternative to legal proceedings and can be faster and cheaper. Depending on the circumstances, binding advice is not a suitable route in all situations.
An executor must act within the limits of the will and the law. In case of suspected exceeding of authority or mismanagement, the court can be asked to dismiss the executor or review their actions. Timely legal assessment is essential to prevent further damage to the estate. This is general information, not individual legal advice.
Yes. A second opinion is also possible if legal proceedings are already underway or if you are being guided by another lawyer. An independent assessment provides insight into the strength of your position and the available routes, without this obliging you to terminate the current guidance.
Trust and quality
Simmelink Lawyers is affiliated with the Dutch Bar Association.
Read more about our reviews or see how we work via our working method.
Would you like to have your position mapped out in an inheritance dispute?
Contact UsOr contact us by phone via: 030 – 30 787 32
